Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Spring Break - Part II

-

If ya missed it, check out Part I here yesterday.

Someone made the point that Reinsdorf is betting on the fans with his decision to open the coffers and allow a $120M payroll this season. A huge part of the Sox bottom line comes in the walk-up for home games, a notoriously fickle group of fans who will stay away in droves when the Sox don't make it worth their while. So if they don't come, the ownership group is going to take a hit in 2011.

That's one of the reasons this increased payroll pumps me up on a ton of levels. Obviously the biggest is that, as I mentioned yesterday, this payroll bump allowed the Sox to retain or acquire pretty much all the pieces they need to enter the season looking as good as any Southside squad I can remember.

But equally important to me is that it shows that Reinsdorf hasn't forgotten the hard-learned lesson of the mid-90s to the mid-2000s. Following the strike, Jerry and his ownership group worked retroactively, only spending the money that was justified by to-date revenues. The result was a mid-market payroll playing in the 3rd largest market in America. And as you all know, Chicago is a diehard sports and diehard baseball town. And the Cubs, as much as they were a nice draw, sucked hard for most of that time.

So it was a bit of a travesty that the White Sox didn't have much of a payroll, especially as free agency became a bigger and bigger deal. What was even more frustrating is that the Sox weren't horrible - they were just mediocre enough to make you think that had they had some extra money - and spent it wisely... I'm looking at you Jamie Navarro and Albert Belle - they could have done more than win one ultimately disappointing division title between 1995 and 2005.

Then in the off-season before 2005 a light went on - Jerry allowed Kenny to push the limits of the payroll beyond what was safe, into the territory that w/o winning, ownership receipts would definitely take a hit. But Kenny wasn't going all Jim Hendry on us, using that extra money to make a media-driven splash that ultimately would play havoc with his on-field team.

Instead, Kenny took those extra millions and found all the small pieces that one needs to win a title. AJ, El Duque, Hermanson, Iguchi - pieces that without the Sox would still be in the same realm of pathetic as the Cubs. That's yet another major reason I'm pumped about this off-season's payroll bump - cause Kenny once again used it for those extra pieces that any championship team needs.

Sure he spent on Dunn and Paulie, but those were no media-splash signings, those were backbone producers with as long a history of production as anyone in baseball who fit exactly into a need we have. The rest went to the AJs, Crains, Castros, and Ohmans of the world. Guys you've got to have to survive the 162-game grind and the equally challenging month-long playoffs.

So it's got me pumped to see that Jerry realized one of the simplest rules of business and investing - you've got to spend money to make money. Before Reinsdorf's strategy was to only spend what he knew he could make, then hope for a breakthrough team that would increase attendance and whatnot, and only THEN, with full coffers, up the payroll.

Now Reinsdorf gets that instead he has to have faith in both his General Manager (and Manager) and the fans. Give Kenny the money to get the players for Ozzie, and they'll produce the kind of team that your millions of diehard Sox fans will happily cough up to see. Since 2005, the Sox have sported a very healthy payroll each year and the fans have responded in kind.

It hasn't always been a full house, but it's night and freakin day from the pre-title days, and it's not just because this team won a championship 5 seasons ago. It's because even in the down years, the Sox have spent the money (and spent it wisely) to the point that Sox fans feel good about going out to the park.

Sox pre-season optimism since 2005 hasn't been a product of naivety and ignorance, as our Northside brethren have perfected. Instead it's been because every year the Sox have had a seemingly solid core surrounded by good role players that if things broke their way, could replicate the magic of 2005. In 2006 and 2010, for large parts of the year they did so (both teams were in 1st at the All-Star Break). In 2008, Game 163 was enough to prove us optimists right. And even in 2007 and 2009, the Sox did enough that all hope wasn't lost... even when those seasons flat-lined the future still remained promising.


Does this mean I support everything that Sox management has done since the title? Of course not - I wrote a bunch last year questioning whether the Kenny/Ozzie combo really had done all that much outside of bringing us 2005 (for which we'll be forever grateful). But the ultimate judgment of their administration is still on-going. With the work they did this off-season to build off the ray of hope we got from that June-July run last year, I'm saying the weight of evidence is leaning back their way. I'm once again in an appreciative mood of Kenny/Ozzie and ultimately, Reinsdorf and his ownership group.

So, to show I'm not just talk I've anted up - I bought seven sets of four seats each to various Half-Priced Mondays throughout the year. I'd suggest you do the same - there are 9 on the schedule, covering every month, and they feature some solid match-ups. And tickets aren't cheap these days - so the half price thing really makes a difference - coming in at only $25 for a bleacher seat (good luck finding a solid seat to any other team in this town for that price).

But not only am I more than happy to do so because I love the games and because I'm uber-pumped about the 2011 Sox, but also because I like supporting an ownership group and management team that has shown a willingness to invest in itself and the fans. So check the Sox schedule and carve out a few nights to come on down and throw in your share... and plan on watching a hell of a Sox club while doing so.

Please go here for Part III and here for Part IV, and check in Friday for Part V.

-

Monday, March 7, 2011

Spring Break - Part I

-

The Sox enter Spring Training with four live, healthy, capable of anything starting pitching arms in the form of Buehrle, Ed Jackson, Floyd, and Danks. Buehrle already has a Perfect Game and No-Hitter on his resume, and Ed Jackson has a no-no of his own. Floyd has tantalized a few times with near no-hitters and won't shock anyone if he finally does it. And it's possible that Danks is the best pitcher of them all.

So when those four guys came out and fired four straight two inning, no run/no hit innings to start Spring Training, my excitement level for 2011 went from 10 to 11.

Alright, it probably more accurately went from a 8 to a 9. For a 10 I'd need to see Morel hitting everything in sight and the young bullpen arms - Sales and Santos - looking untouchable. And to hit Spinal Tap's vaunted 11? That would take a string of Jake Peavy starts that show he's as strong and effective as ever.

Oh wait... lookie at what Jakie did his first time out - he got himself his own 2 innings of scoreless, hitless work to kick of his Cactus League campaign. Where's that leave us - 30 straight outs with not a single hit or run against our starting rotation to start the pre-season.


Still, not quite an 11 yet, but hell's yeah I'm pumped to see those five guys dealing as they have. I wrote about this a lot last year - when we were on our hot streak in 2010, the starting pitchers were driving the train. Every game it looked as if the day's starter was out to one-up the guy from the night before. Memories of 2005 danced in my head as this team went on an unholy tear from June 9th to the All-Star Break.

Of course, after the All-Star Break the Sox were very middling, quickly fell out of the race with the Twinkies, and I was faced with yet another disappointing season on the South Side (probably my 28th in 30 years... I'll grant that the Game 163 win was enough to label 2008 satisfactory).

But with the calendar flipped to 2011, somehow Kenny retained all the key vets we were supposed to lose and also somehow found the coin to upgrade all over the place. Dunn was the big splash, but don't sleep on Crain, Ohman, or even Lastings Milledge. Similarly, getting AJ and Paulie back was tremendous, but re-signing Castro, Pena, and Vizquel should also prove crucial at various points this season. And one last tip of the hat - not parting with Ed Jackson (or any SP) or Quentin, despite the many talks that one or both needed to go.

Personally I think it's almost always a dumb move for any team that has a legit chance to contend for the playoffs to ever get rid of proven effective starting or relief pitching. I've just never seen a team have too much of those. Injuries, ineffectiveness, and all sorts of other random things sprout up to make every single arm you have necessary to success. Only rarely will you find a team that truly has too many arms to the point that they're better served dealing some.

The Sox aren't there - instead the fact that we're 4.5 frontline capable guys deep (which hopefully will round up to a 5 as Peavy proves healthy and sharp) in the rotation is huge to me. And the fact that these guys are already out there dealing means even more. Sure it's the first outing of Spring Training, sure both Floyd and Buehrle followed up with 3 ER outings. But it still was impressive to see all five of these starters to come flying out of the gate. Especially after what we dealt with last year, seeing are big guns chomping at the bit to prove their worth is very encouraging. It speaks to a preparation, a drive, and a camaraderie that is exactly what we rode to the 2005 title.


Now while Peavy is most certainly the biggest question mark, he's also got the most room to help this club. Imagine if the other four guys are dealing during the year, pacing us to a Central Division lead and a favored status in the AL when the doldrums of the season hit in July and August. Who should just be rounding into prime form then... none other than your 2007 Cy Young winner, an ultra-competitive sort who seems uniquely qualified to be that stretch run and post-season Ace you wanna have.

Now I'd argue that Contreras was no better than Buehrle, Big Game Fred, or Garland in the 2005 Postseason, but there is zero question that we'd never have gotten there if Jose hadn't been lights out in the second half. He was that much-needed stopper to slow the August/September free-fall. And I think mentally it helped the rotation to know that Jose would take the ball in Game 1 each series, with everyone else able to fall into whatever place after that.

So I'm not counting on Peavy early on. Instead, I just need him to get healthy in May or even June (no hurry in April, where a 5th starter is barely needed). And then I need him to work out the kinks - mentally and physically - so he's ready to deal in the second half straight on through October. He needs to slot into that unquestioned Ace role, so that the other four guys can fill in #2-5, where they probably fit best.


So yeah, I'm a pretty big Kenny fan for how he's assembled and kept together this rotation. I'm also pumped with how he's stewarded our bullpen. Keeping Sale in a spot where he's proven he can be highly effective and where the odds are far greater than he can remain so for the full season is great call. And while you hate to mess with what works, the steady consistency Thornton has shown after years and years of working the most stressful late-inning situations (how many times when there was trouble a-brewin in the 7th and 8th, did you see Ozzie motion for the lefty and big Matt came hustling out of the pen?) leads me to believe he'll be a money closer.

Throw in that Crain's proven a steady 7th/8th inning righty, that Santos has the upside to be as good as any of these guys, and that Ohman is an accomplished professional situational lefty and I love what our relief corps look like. Wait - can't forget about Tony Pena, who has, pre-Sox days, been a viable late-inning option and also proved last year that he could be as good as anyone in baseball in mop up work and even spot start duty.

So while I've said it a million times, let me do so again - there are few things are crucial to a ballclub as having lights out relief pitching. You show me a team that has 4-5 consistent options out of the pen and I'll show you a team that is contending, regardless of what else they've got. And tho you never know what the hell you're gonna get out of a pen, I think Kenny has built as good of one as we could have expected.


Yeah, it's easy to cherry pick what you want to see in Spring Training and make more of it than it is. But I consider myself a fairly critical off-season fan - I love predicting and following all the moves and strategies, and as you've seen around here, I've got plenty of my own opinions on it all. But this off-season I gotta give Kenny the credit that he's built a club that deserves our optimism.

Top to bottom, core guys to role players, we've got it all... on paper. Now we just need to see if they can get it done on the field. So far, there are some signs that not only is the talent there - as we figured - but that they've also got the right attitude. I won't put too much stock into Spring numbers much going forward, but if the numbers seem to add up to something more - such as all five starters firing off beauty outings in succession their first time out - then I'm gonna let it up my excitement level. Maybe even to 11.

Please go here for Part II, here for Part III, and here for Part IV, and check in Friday for Part V.

-

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Another Key Piece... But Now What?

-

I'm gonna start by reiterating what I preached on and on about when the Sox first traded for Teahen, and was even more incensed about after they gave him that absolutely indefensible, asinine 3-year extension that pays him $4.75M this year and $5.5M in 2012!?!

This guy is the poster child for mediocrity, doing a bunch of stuff just below average, without doing a single thing well. Yes, Teahen can hit left-handed, play 1B, 3B, LF, and RF, and isn't terrible in speed, power, average, or contact.

But Teahen's not good at a single one of those things - sure he's a lefty, but he's not giving you numbers you're happy about no matter which side they come from. Sure he can play any corner spot - infield or outfield - but he's not much of a defender at any of them (and looked like he really shouldn't be a 3B for more than maybe a game every week or two). And offensively, Teahen's a .260 hitter with little power who will K too much and not walk enough, who isn't exactly threatening Pierre for the team lead in steals.

The reason I'm bringing this all back up is that contract extension is looking SO painful in the face of what we're dealing with today. At best Teahen is a 1B-3B-LF-RF bench guy. I'd say he's probably comparable to a Kotsay or Blum, both of whom will make around $1-$1.5M this year. So Teahen is essentially pissing away $3.5M of Sox money each of the next two years that they desperately could have used elsewhere.

Now for some clubs, this would be only a mild annoyance. Take the Yanks or BoSox, whose payrolls are strictly based on how much money the owners want to make that year. For them, if they need that $3.5M to get a key reliever or middle infielder to put them over the top, the owners will just shrink the profits they'll make with the hope of recouping it due to a more successful team.

For other clubs, like the Cubs or Orioles, you're not really close to contending anyway, so no $3.5M piece is really making a discernible difference on the final outcome of your 2011 season anyway. So why care?

But the White Sox? That $3.5M is the difference between a revolving door of unready prospects and washed up journeymen blowing key games out of your pen, and a steady, proven veteran reliever getting the ball to your set-up men on the way to another big W.


Or at least, that's what I would have thought before yesterday. The Sox payroll was reportedly tapped out, with every last dime and creative maneuver already utilized to bring Paulie and AJ back while still adding Dunn to the fold. Holding tight seemed to be the best option, with subtraction a possibility.

And that was fine, as the team looked fairly close to where you needed it to be, and with the exception of Teahen, almost all the money was very well-spent. The one issue - a glaring hole (or maybe two) still remained in the bullpen, a place that you simply cannot win w/o being strong. And a place that $3.5M can make all the difference.

But late Wednesday, the Sox somehow found another $4M per to bring aboard Jesse Crain. Not sure how, not sure what this will mean going forward, all I know is that Crain fits the bill perfectly for what the Sox needed most, and the Sox management team somehow made it happen despite all indications that there was no more money to be spent.

Crain has been one of the many seemingly interchangeable arms that come out of the Twins pen and lock down games, especially against the Sox. He's a 29-year old right-hander who has had bouts of inconsistency due to somewhat iffy control and not over-powering stuff, but yet still has been a crucial part of the Twin's relief staff since he first came up in 2004.

Crain's shown that he's good for a 3.40 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, and about 50 Ks and 25 walks in 60 IP. Those numbers aren't stellar, but they're pretty good and can work for a #2 or #3 righty out of the pen. Especially because Crain has often been much better than that - it's just that he'll struggle for stretches, as he did when an injury in 2007 robbed him of a bit of his effectiveness for a few seasons.

Now the thing with relievers is you never know what you're going to get. Linebrink showed that - after being one of baseball most dominant set-up men for a number of years, he struggled to be effective after the first few months of each season on the Southside, putting up disastrous 2nd halves every year he was here.

However, Linebrink made his mark in the NL and throwing out of PetCo in San Diego, the league's most pitcher-friendly park. On the other hand, while the MetroDome is less hitter-friendly than the Cell, Crain's been equally effective on the road over his career and, much more importantly, has proven he can get it done in the AL Central.

Still, there's a little bit of caution here in that before last year, Crain hadn't had a WHIP below 1.27 since his first full year in the bigs in 2005. For a guy who's not a high strike-out arm (far less than a K/IP over his career), that's a lot of hitters for a reliever to be putting on base. And before last year, he hadn't been all that effective since the 2007 injury, with an ERA in the high 3s or worse.

But having raised the requisite red flags, I'm still high on this signing for two reasons. First, as I keep saying, the Sox most definitely needed another proven veteran arm to have any chance of success in 2011. They still aren't perfect out there (I'd like to see one more arm with some late-inning upside and Pena brought back into the mix), but at least they're close enough that you can hope the rest can be cobbled together off the scrap heap or out of the system.

Because make no mistake, Crain's got as much ability to be a strong 7th/8th inning guy as anyone out there. Before his injury in 2006, he'd been pretty lights out to start his career. And beginning about midway through 2009, Crain started to look like that pitcher once again. He finished that season almost untouchable in the second half, struggled a bit to start 2010, and then returned to being one of Gardenhire's most reliable late-inning options.

Seeing those pair of second half surges, I went and looked at Crain's career splits and was impressed by what I saw - this is a guy who gets stronger as the year goes on. Year in and year out, he consistently seems to stumble here and there in the first half before putting it all together around mid-season.

Over his career, Crain's posted a pretty poor 4.14 ERA and 1.37 WHIP in the 1st half. So know that Crain might seem a bit of a bust early on. I'm sure the fans will probably get on him about this, but I hope Ozzie is able to show some patience and confidence in this guy, because the Sox need a reliever who can get it done down the stretch.

The way the Sox pen has fallen apart pretty much every year under Ozzie, it's nice to have a guy like Crain who will be there to pick up some of the slack. In second halves over his career, he's posted a sparkling 2.72 ERA and a 1.15 WHIP. If Crain repeats that kind of down-then-up performance in 2011, I'll be very happy with this move. I think it'll go a long way to giving us the late-season stability in the pen, the lack of which helped tanked good Sox teams in 2006 and 2010.

The second reason I'm high on this signing? Because Kenny is on record, in response to the Quentin rumors, that he would not be weakening one part of his team to improve another. So if he's not looking to deal CQ because of how it'd hurt the lineup (and all the latest reports affirm that Kenny respectfully listened to overtures but made no effort to part with CQ), you've got to figure he also won't be looking to deal Ed Jackson (as some have theorized might be the follow-up move to get the payroll back to levels the Sox have previously proven comfortable with).

And nor should Kenny be considering something like that. Even if Peavy is declared fit to pitch tomorrow, would you really be confident in him getting around 30 starts this year? And as durable as Danks, Floyd, and Buehrle have been, it's rare for a team to avoid injuries to all four of its top starters.

Given that you've built a team capable to win this year, that you can't hope to do so w/o strong starting pitching up and down the rotation, and that you're already taxing your depth with Peavy's uncertainty, the Sox are in no place to consider dealing Ed Jackson (or any of their other starter) unless they're just blown away.


So where does that leave the Sox? Apparently at a payroll approaching $125M (after assumed arbitration salaries are included). Is that sustainable? Since the winning the World Series, the Sox have been around $100-$110M. Now they did spike up to over $120 in 2008, but since then they've lost a bit of the revenue bounce they got from the title, have seen an epic recession, and don't have any salary offsets coming in (such as the $3.5M the Dodgers gave the Sox for Pierre, which they Sox then gave to the Braves to cover Linebrink).

Assuming what Kenny says is true, that they aren't moving key pieces, that leaves really only two salaries the Sox can hope to shed at this point - the above-mentioned Teahen's $4.75M (and another $5.5M next year) and Viciedo's $2.25M (and $3.25M next year). Even that's only $6M in savings this year (over the min level guys you'll still need to fill out your bench) and it's extremely unlikely anyone is gonna agree to take on all that wasted money on Teahen unless you're giving up a pretty good prospect or sending over cash (which defeats the purpose).

But maybe that's what's gonna happen. Maybe Kenny does part with a quality prospect in order to move Teahen off the books, under the thinking that it's no different than trading a quality prospect for a reliever (as Teahen's money could be seen as used for Crain). And maybe Viciedo is shipped out, bringing back that very same quality prospect.

Maybe it means pairing Viciedo with Teahen to some team with a little bit of money who loves Viciedo's upside. Not unreasonable, given how Viciedo raked last year in AAA - .274 AVG and .493 SLG in 343 ABs - and the bigs - .308 AVG, .519 SLG in 104 ABs. This kid might just be a great young power-hitting 3B (or more likely, 1B) who's cheap and has loads of upside. That might be worth taking on some garbage salary in Teahen for some team.

And it would make perfect sense for the Sox, who don't seem to have a place for Viciedo moving forward. Konerko and Dunn have 1B/DH locked up, while moving Dunn to LF isn't an option because of Pierre and whomever takes over the leadoff spot (say Jordan Danks) in 2012. It's questionable whether Viciedo can play fulltime 3B, especially on a team that is built around defense, not to mention how the Sox seem pretty committed to Morel anyway.

The Sox could keep him in AAA - Viciedo will only be 22 on Opening Day - but he's getting a bit expensive for that now and that's still only a temporary solution. Worst case he takes a step back and loses all value - while still costing you money - and best case is that he hits so well that you can't keep him down for much longer.

However, maybe that temporary solution is worth it, as who knows what the future brings. Morel hit like crap in his big league stint last year, and as we've seen with Crede and Fields, there's no guarantee that he'll be a solid player any time soon. An injury to Konerko or Dunn or even Quentin might make a hot-hitting Viciedo a perfect short term stop gap. Or an injury or ineffective play elsewhere might make Viciedo the perfect mid-season trade piece.


I've got to be honest, I have no idea where these Sox are heading from here this off-season. I laid out my thoughts for the hitters in my little position-by-position state of the union and touched on what I thought the Sox should do about the pitching in my summary post after the Dunn, Konerko, and AJ moves.

But at this point, the Sox have gone in such a different direction from what I originally thought and put themselves in such an unexpected position that I can't really say what the next moves Kenny will be making are. Maybe nothing. Maybe he just finds some crap heap types to compete to round out the pen and bench and 6th starter spot and lets Spring Training determine the make-up of the final roster.

If that's the case, if the Sox really are going to keep their payroll where it is now and hold tight with their roster and prospects as is, I think I'm ready to declare this off-season a success. The questions that remain are ones you can hope to "figure out" in Spring Training, such as pen, bench, and rotation depth.

Otherwise, you can look at the team you have now and say it has pretty much everything you need to be a World Series champ. Speed, run production, defense, bench depth, stellar rotation, and a strong pen. Fill in the depth pieces with those random guys Kenny and Ozzie are good at finding and why couldn't we be watching another South Side parade next October?


-

Thursday, December 9, 2010

The Carlos Question

-

Last week, (here) I laid out the expected Sox 25-man roster based on what they've got under contract now.

Lineup:
1 - Pierre (LF)
2 - Beckham (2B)
3 - Konerko (1B)
4 - Dunn (DH)
5 - Rios (CF)
6 - Quentin (RF)
7 - AJ (C)
8 - Alexei (SS)
9 - Morel (3B)

Bench:
C - Castro
1B/LF/RF - Teahen
2B/3B/SS - Vizquel
CF - ???

Rotation:
1 - Peavy
2 - Buehrle
3 - Floyd
4 - Danks
5 - EJackson

Bullpen:
CL - Thornton
LSU - Sale
RSU - Santos
LMR - ???
RMR - ???
MR - ???

*Plus a bench hitter or extra bullpen arm

I ended the post saying that there was one more big thought the above lay-out inspired and today I share it with you:

-Rumors flew around this weekend that Quentin was now available. But then Kenny came out and said that while he knew he needed to upgrade the pen, he would not do so by taking away from his starting lineup. He didn't think that made sense to weaken one area to help another.

I totally disagree. Look at that lineup and you realize that CQ is not necessary at all. Paulie-Dunn-Rios are a plenty good 3-4-5 combo, while after that AJ and Alexei are more than respectable 6-7 options. This team has enough power that it can replace Quentin with a low cost option, maybe even a platoon, of the type of OF vagabonds you find floating around.

I'm not talking about garbage scrap heapers like Andruw Jones (who was respectable last season, if a bit over-exposed). I mean proven big league bats who can play good outfield defense at a few different spots, move a little bit on the bases, and combine just enough average, power, and OBA to warrant semi-regular at-bats in the back of your lineup.

Think about what happens if you move Quentin:

1) You get a bunch of assets back.

This is a guy who's proven he can put up MVP numbers in the bigs. Sure the reality of CQ is what we got in 09-10 (30 HR power, 10 RBI production, low average, solid OBA, and lots of injuries), but the fact that Quentin's 2008 exists jumps his value significantly. There just aren't that many guys who've shown they can do that, even inconsistently.

On top of that, CQ is young and under team control for another two seasons. Most teams can't afford market prices for middle of the order bats, so the chance to slot CQ for maybe $5M and $8M the next few seasons is pretty attractive to most clubs. Especially because he's a class guy who's played both left and right - there aren't a lot of things to give you pause aside those nagging injuries. But they haven't cost CQ a whole season or anything, and you're not tied into a big, longterm contract or anything.

I could definitely see Quentin bringing back a nice young major league ready bullpen arm with good potential and maybe another prospect or two to help re-stock the system a bit. Teams always have young arms and prospects - sure they're valuable as ever now, but aside a stud young starting pitcher, nothing is more valuable than a cheap young middle of the order producer.

So find that promising young pitching prospect who isn't slated to be a starter but looks like (or even has already proven that) he's able to get outs in the 6th or 7th innings. Build a deal around him and whatever other minor league assets you can get. The trade market for a guy like Quentin most definitely exists, as Quentin's name is always coming up in trade rumors, and apparently that's not of the Sox doing. Especially this off-season, when there aren't much for big bats in free agency nor many viable trade options.

2) You upgrade your OF defense and possibly find a better 2-hole option.

By every measure Quentin is a pretty bad OF. He was serviceable in left, using his plus arm and the general mediocrity of this position across baseball to be OK, but in right the numbers suggest he's hurting you a bit out there. It wasn't terribly obvious when watching him, but it also wasn't obvious watching Dye in 2009, but by every metric he was about the worst RF in baseball that season.

So it's easy to discount the value of a good defensive OF or not realize the harm of a poor one, but given the Sox investment in starting pitching, this team needs good defense to be successful. Your starters aren't gonna fill their potential if you don't have guys behind them who can get the job done. And upgrading your RF defense - fairly easy to do from Quentin to some journeyman, given that you can expect to get good D if you aren't demanding a great bat - will make a real difference.

On top of that, it shouldn't be difficult to find one of these plus OF defender types w/o a real high impact bat but with the ability to make contact, put down bunts, work the count, and hit just well enough when facing only righties or lefties to fulfill the role of a #2 hitter. These guys are generally platoon types or 4th OFs, especially in the NL, and very much exist in some abundance.

3) You free up money to spend on your pen.

I gotta figure CQ is gonna jump from $3.2M to $5-6M, maybe more. The guy drove in 87 runs last year, despite missing a bunch of time, and has that tremendous 2008 on his resume. I can't say I'm great at guessing arbitration numbers, but certainly it won't be less than $5M or so, and could be up near $7M or even $8M.

The Sox know about what number they're looking at to keep CQ and have built that into their payroll math. So when they say they're tapped, that includes the $5-$8M they are going to have spend on CQ next year. But if they deal him, suddenly that money is freed up. You figure you can find a decent platoon of solid defensive RFs capable of hitting #2 for about $3-4M total, giving you another $2-4M to go and spend on the pen.

That could mean another top notch arm like Putz last year, or it could be a couple of solid veteran journeymen, like a respectable 6th-7th inning spot righty (think Vizcaino from the 05 team) coupled with a 2nd tier lefty (think Marte from the 05 team).


However the Sox would spend the money, the simple fact is that as the pen stands right now, the Sox are set up for disaster in 2011. I know everyone's all pumped for this lineup, to have AJ and Paulie back while somehow also adding Dunn. On paper the Sox look amazing. But the pen is the easiest area to overlook when analyzing a team and yet by far the most crucial to getting to and advancing in the playoffs.

Think 2006 - that's what I see in this team right now. A ton of offense. A great lineup of SPs. And a couple of pen arms you can rely on mashed together with a whole bunch of question marks.

So what happened in 2006? We got off to an incredible first half, as good as any team in baseball at the All-Star Break, looking like a real perennial power. But then the pen started having issues and suddenly everything else fell apart. The lineup and rotation had too much pressure on them w/ the way the pen was blowing games and ultimately the second half was a disaster, netting the most disappointing 90-win season in Sox history.

What really spooks me about that prediction is that 2006 was far from the only season that the pen melted down in the second half. My brother made the point that there seems to be something to how Ozzie uses his guys that leaves them susceptible to injuries or ineffectiveness shortly after the All-Star Break. It happened last year and also was a concern in 2008, even tho we fought through it to win the division. And while we weren't much for competitive in 07 or 09, the pens were definitely worse late in the year than early on.

Some of the solution lies in Ozzie learning to better use his pen early on. Don't always go 7-8-9. Don't always go to your stud set-up guy in every sign of trouble, nor bring out your closer whenever the game isn't a laugher in the 9th. Protect these guys every chance you can get, work hard to get them strings of days off to really allow for some recovery in-season. And develop the lesser guys so later in the year they're experienced in dealing with some of the tough situations that arise.

But the real foundation to answering the Sox bullpen problems comes from loading up on as many capable arms as possible. As it stands, the Sox have two sure-things in their pen - Thornton and Santos. And I don't mean sure-things in terms of effectiveness - only Mariano Rivera is a sure thing bullpen arm. Everyone else it's year-to-year, outing-to-outing.

I mean sure-thing in that they will be crucial parts of the Sox relief staff in 2011. Otherwise, it's all up in the air. Personally I'd like to see Thornton closing and Sale as the 7th/8th inning lefty option. I think Sale showed himself fully capable of the job last year and I don't see any reason to mess with success.

The argument would be that the Sox have a lot of money tied up in their rotation and no guarantee these guys will be around longterm, so you've got to develop that next generation of starters. But I'm not buying that totally. Sure there's some truth to it and if I could be sure Sale would be an effective starter, I'd say let's do it.

But I'm not at all sure of that - the kid hasn't started ever at the professional level. So far Sale's been purely a reliever in the bigs and minors, and he's done a tremendous job of it. Why fix what ain't broke? Especially because relievers are tremendously valuable - as I said, they're so unpredictable that if you find one - like Thornton - who delivers every night for seasons on end, he can be just as important to your success as a middle rotation starter.

So I'm sticking with Sale in the pen, using Thornton to close, and letting Santos work a 7th/8th role. But I'm also making sure I get another possible 7th/8th back in a Quentin deal, and then using the savings there to bring in another reliable 7th/8th option or a pair of 6th/7th options that might just have 7th/8th upside.

My theory with a pen is that you aren't going to get what you expect, so you need to have a ton of different options to make up for the injuries and ineffectiveness that nearly every team in baseball goes through in its pen over the course of a 162 game season (not to mention playoffs). Think about 2005 - Shingo flames out early, so Hermanson takes over. He gets hurt, so Jenks steps in. But it didn't end there - Hermanson's move out of the set-up role only worked because Politte was able to step into it. And when Marte proved unreliable, the Sox couldn't have sniffed a series title without Cotts there to dominate as a 7th/8th lefty.

Sure, a lot of that was luck - Politte and Cotts didn't have another good season the rest of their careers after being as untouchable as any set-up men I've ever seen. But Politte had closed before and Cotts came with a strong pedigree. While they initially were counted on only as spot guys in middle relief, there were some signs that they might just have what it takes to step up if need be.

That's what Kenny needs to assemble - a pen that not only looks good in it's closer and set-up spots, but also has 2nd and even 3rd options for every role to deal with whatever troubles come the Sox way. It ain't easy to do it, but if the Sox don't get creative and figure it out, then


-

Dunn, AJ, Paulie... and then?

-

After making one of the first big splashes of the off-season with the Dunn signing, Kenny wasted no time bringing AJ back into the fold and after a bit of back-and-forth and showing some impressive creativity on the Sox side and flexibility on Konerko's side, the team was able to keep the Captain around for another three seasons as well.

Where does this leave the Sox for the rest of the off-season? Apparently, tapped out financially, which seems to make sense after giving Dunn $13M.

The savings you got from dumping Linebrink ($2M), Jenks ($7.5M), Kotsay ($1.5M), and Freddy ($1M), the drop in Pierre's salary ($1.5M), and the creative structuring of AJ's contract (only $2M in 2011, after $6.25 in 2010) is mostly eaten up by contractual raises to Peavy ($1M), Rios ($2.3M), Alexei ($1.5M), Teahen ($1M - to $4.75M... yes, we're paying this bum almost $5M!), Floyd ($2.25M), and Thornton ($1M), plus the impending Arbitration raises that Danks, Quentin, and possibly even Pena (more on him later) will get.

Looking at those numbers, it's impressive they even found $13M for Dunn, so I believe Kenny when he says that as things stand today, they've got no more room to make any significant adds.

So how does that leave our Sox looking, assuming that they don't make any more moves?

Lineup:
1 - Pierre (LF)
2 - Beckham (2B)
3 - Konerko (1B)
4 - Dunn (DH)
5 - Rios (CF)
6 - Quentin (RF)
7 - AJ (C)
8 - Alexei (SS)
9 - Morel (3B)

Bench:
C - Castro
1B/LF/RF - Teahen
2B/3B/SS - Vizquel
CF - ???

Rotation:
1 - Peavy
2 - Buehrle
3 - Floyd
4 - Danks
5 - EJackson

Bullpen:
CL - Thornton
LSU - Sale
RSU - Santos
LMR - ???
RMR - ???
MR - ???

*Plus a bench hitter or extra bullpen arm


My thoughts:

-Personally not a fan of Becks in the #2 slot, especially behind Pierre, as I think he's far better off further down where he can just hit, instead of needing to wait for Pierre to steal, then need to hit behind the runner, execute hit-and-runs, and so on. This kid struggled once already - let's put Beckham in a spot to succeed, really prove himself just as a hitter, before asking him to fill a challenging and vital role.

Let's not repeat the hard-learned lessons of last season's horrendous start, please. Especially after seeing a good, but not unbeatable Texas team get through the AL, I absolutely believe that with the starting arms the Sox had and their solid lineup, we could have made some real noise in the post-season. Reminded me a lot of 2003, when another well-built Sox club missed the playoffs thanks to a terrible start that gave them no room for error down the stretch.

Now I get why Ozzie is thinking Beckham is his #2 - he doesn't have any other clear options (unlike last year, when Kotsay was so obviously the right answer). But, at least to start off, I'd use AJ here instead. Then if Beckham comes out swinging the bat great, I might move him up to #2. But take the pressure off early.

Sure, AJ is far from ideal, as it puts two lefties back-to-back and takes away any southpaws from the back of your order. And of course, AJ isn't exactly the dictionary definition of a #2 hitter. But they won with him at #2 in 2008 and I just think about how AJ approaches at-bats, loves to bunt or hit behind runners, runs smart on the bases, and is well-versed in the Twins school of fundamental baseball.

To me, that makes him the best option the Sox currently have in their starting lineup to fill the #2 hitter responsibilities that hitting behind Pierre and in front of Konerko and Dunn demands. And a good manager thinks outside the box a bit and makes these kind of calls.

Though what I think I'd really do is start Vizquel at 3B and let him be my #2 hitter. He showed last season he's got everything it takes - respectable average, good at-bats, great bunter, decent speed and good base-running. But it sounds like the Sox really want to keep Vizquel as a Util guy - I can see that, given his age and need for that bench 2B/SS. But unless Morel or Viciedo really shows they can get the job done, I wouldn't hesitate starting the year with Omar at 3B and in the #2 slot.

In fact, my approach would be to let Vizquel show you that he's too old to get it done before you write him off. I hate when teams go into the off-season and decide that because on paper it's time to move from a proven vet to a promising youngster, that they're just gonna go ahead and do it.

I'd far prefer to see Morel to come into camp with something to prove. Tell him the job's Vizquel's and he's got to show he deserves it more. And let Vizquel know that as long as he does what he's done, the position is his to lose. That's how it should be, but so many GMs and Managers are too proactive, forcing things they want to be the case before they actually are.

What I really like about this plan is that it gives you a lot of room for error. If Vizquel struggles early, at least he'll still be doing the little things to help as a #2 hitter and plus defensive 3B. With Beckham in the #2 slot and Morel as an everyday 3B, if either doesn't do well, they're gonna start screwing up their confidence and also not contribute a whole lot to the team.

Instead, put them both in a position to succeed early - Beckham down in the order and Morel in Spring Training and a Minor League stint without any expectations, but instead a challenge to prove himself. Once both of those guys are up and grooving, then you can slot Beckham into the #2 hole and Morel onto the big league club as your 3B.


-There are some talks of batting Dunn #3 behind Beckham, but that would mean once Dunn bats, pitchers are facing righties the rest of the way thru the heart of the order, with AJ the only respite until JP comes around at #1 again. Konerko might not be ideal as a #3 hitter - I don't see him repeating his .300 average again this year - but he's a real presence in the lineup, especially with the likes of Dunn protecting him. With Dunn's lefty bat in the clean-up slot, you're now going R-L-R through 3-4-5, and that challenges pitchers and managers.

Now I'm not one to overplay the importance of righty-lefty (as the Sox did last year, with Kotsay at the #5 slot, or by using the RBI-light AJ there in the past), but if you have the option to utilize R-L to your advantage, then you should do so.


-I love Rios at #5 - after a pair of cloggers like Konerko and Dunn, it's great that you'll start to get into some athleticism. Quentin actually doesn't move bad at #6 and Alexei can really fly at #8. You start mixing speed throughout your lineup and not only do you make yourself more dangerous to other teams, but it will keep Ozzie from falling asleep at the wheel while he waits for 3-run homers.

Aside Konerko and Dunn, you've got a lineup that can steal and do hit-and-runs top to bottom, and that kind of approach to the game keeps your offense more steady and consistent. And as I've harped on in the past - you've got to build a lineup that inspires Ozzie to manage, else he'll happily not do so and blame it on his personnel.


-I'm very curious to see who will be the bench CF option and also whether the Sox will carry 7 relievers or 5 bench hitters. It's a small thing, but still important, especially the way Ozzie uses his bench much like an NL coach. A lot will go into this and we probably won't know until Opening Day, but it'll be interesting to see it shake out.

Will Viciedo forces his way onto the roster if he isn't the everyday 3B? It could happen if he rakes in Spring Training but Morel if looks solid too, he'll get the nod for his defense. So what then - how are you gonna get Viciedo at-bats w/ Dunn and Paulie around and Morel also a righty?

What about the OF? Right now Teahen is the only bench guy who can play OF and he's not a CF. So they're gonna have to add someone and with CQ out there, possibly Dunn on occasion, you're gonna need a CF-capable guy who's fairly strong defensively for the late innings. Ozzie has shown he can get a lot out of the guys Kenny finds for him, so I'm curious who this will be.


-The Sox are saying they're going to be very cautious with Peavy, which they should be, given that he's owed $16M this year, $17M next year, and the club holds what is essentially an $18M option the following year ($22M w/ a $4M buy-out). Throw in the fact that this is an injury you generally see in QBs but not pitchers, and a slow, cautious approach makes perfect sense.

The problem is that it's not easy to gameplan around missing your #1 starter for anywhere between 1 and 3 months. I loved the Freddy Garcia pick up last year and it proved to be genius - they would have been also-rans all season if it wasn't for his 9-3 record before the All-Star Break.

But not only can you not bring back Freddy, you'll have a hard time finding someone similar to sign on for a non-guaranteed role on the team after a month or so. Proven guys like Freddy won't come cheap enough nor will be happy with an uncertain role. And unproven guys - like Freddy was last year coming off his injuries - won't want to come somewhere they aren't guaranteed a chance to re-establish their value.

So the Sox are going to have to get creative, either by finding a viable arm out of their group of prospects or matching up with a trash heap guy who's so desperate for a chance that he'll accept this uncertain role. On thing I hope they don't do, which is something there is a lot of talk of them doing, is use Sale in the spot. I'll talk more on this later, but in brief I'd rather not sacrifice a seemingly sure asset in a great area of need to be a 5th starter maybe just for a month.

One thing I'd like to see the Sox look into - Tony Pena. He's arbitration eligible, so it's possible they non-tender him and he moves on, much like what happened with DJ Carrasco last year (who, by the way, had another productive season out of the pen - not sure why the Sox dumped an effective reliever who could fill any role when such reliable guys are so hard to come by, especially when he signed for peanuts).

Pena only made $1.2M last year, hasn't had impressive numbers, and is in only his 2nd arbitration year - how expensive could he be? And if arbitration would bring Pena a salary that doesn't fit the market (as it often does), isn't it possible to non-tender the guy but still bring him back for a price that's good for both sides? Especially if you're offering him a chance to be a starting pitcher (which ups his earning power), something no one else is going to do?

I really think Pena has a shot to be an ideal short-term #5 starter. He showed himself shockingly good when given multiple innings of work - in the 13 appearances where he racked up 3+ IP this past year, Pena was quality in 9 or 10 of them.

Pena also got what equated to 4 starts this past season, counting when he took over for Floyd after 7 pitches (and no outs). Pena had a respectable 4 ER on 5 hits and 0 BB over 7 IP, then finished the year with a 6 inning, 0 ER game and a 6 IP, 3 ER outing before struggling in his final start to the tune of 6 ER in 6 IP.

It's only four games, but if he could keep that up - 1 great, 2 OK, and 1 bad start in every four - Pena would be a perfect #5 starter, especially for only part of the season. And I have faith he could - for whatever reason last year, when Pena was tasked with throwing a lot of innings, he rose to the challenge. Aside the respectable four starts, he also had two other 4+ inning outings where he allowed either no runs or 1 run.

Another thing I like about using Pena in this role is that he also is able to seamlessly move back into the bullpen to fill that spot and long relief role like he did in the past. So you're not getting a guy just to sub for Peavy, but also to shore up the pen. Especially because in 2007 and the first half of 2008, Pena was a plus set-up man. That means he's one more guy who might randomly turn into a late-inning bullpen option next year. As I'll get into more later, most successful bullpens feature at least a guy or two who came out of nowhere to play a key late-inning role. Pena gives you one more reasonable option for one of those break-outs.


I've still got one more thought inspired by this look at the Sox current roster, but it's a bit of a long and multi-dimensional one, and this post is already pretty full of stuff to chew on, so I'll save it for next week (here).


-